It’s probably not an exaggeration to say that most investors begin their robo-advisor search with one or both these platforms.
Betterment vs. Wealthfront – which is the better of the two? Let’s drill down into the details and see if we can come to a conclusion.
We’re going to get into considerable detail in analyzing the differences between the two robo-advisors. But the table below summarizes and compares the basic service levels and other features offered by each investment platform:
|Minimum Initial Investment||$0 Digital; $100,000 Premium||$500|
|Accounts Available||Individual and joint taxable accounts; traditional, Roth, SEP and rollover IRAs; trusts and non-profits||Individual and joint taxable accounts; traditional, Roth, SEP and rollover IRAs; trusts and 529 plans|
|Advisory Fees||Digital: 0.25% to $2 million; 0.15% over $2 million; Premium: 0.40% to $2 million; 0.30% over $2 million||0.25%|
|Mobile App||Android & iOS devices||Android & iOS devices|
|Socially Responsible Investing||Yes||Yes, through Smart Beta and Stock-level Tax-loss Harvesting (min. Investment $100,000)|
|Smart Beta||Yes||Yes with $500,000 minimum investment|
Betterment is the largest independent robo-advisor in the industry, with at least $13.5 billion in assets under management. The company was founded in 2008, and is based in New York City.
Like all robo-advisors, Betterment uses Modern Portfolio Theory (MTP) to create and manage your investment portfolio. MPT stresses proper asset allocation based on targeted risk levels.
Signing up for Betterment
You can sign up for the platform with no money at all. The first step will involve completing a brief questionnaire, that will identify your investment goals, time horizon, and risk tolerance level.
Your portfolio will then be created from a mix of 14 different asset classes, including six for stocks and eight for fixed income investments. Each asset class will be represented by an individual exchange traded fund (ETF), giving your portfolio exposure to literally thousands of individual securities. Each ETF is tied to an index representing the entire asset class it represents.
Once your portfolio has been created, it will be fully managed on an ongoing basis. That will include automatic dividend reinvesting, periodic rebalancing to maintain target asset allocations, and even tax-loss harvesting to minimize capital gains taxes in taxable accounts.
The use of index-based ETFs and automated investment management keeps investing expenses low, maximizing your investment returns. Betterment offers both taxable and tax-sheltered retirement accounts.
Learn more about Betterment: read our full review or visit their site!
Wealthfront is the second largest independent robo-advisor, with at least $10 billion in assets under management. The company is based in Redwood City, California, and began operations in October, 2011.
Wealthfront works much the same as Betterment and other robo-advisors. It uses modern portfolio theory, and invests your money in various asset classes, each represented by an index-based ETF. However, Wealthfront allocates your portfolio across fewer – but more diversified – asset classes.
For example, it uses just three stock classes – US stocks, foreign developed stocks, and emerging market stocks. It also uses just four fixed income classes, one of which is dividend stocks, which may add a growth component to an income generating asset class.
But where Wealthfront departs from Betterment is that it also diversifies into natural resource stocks and real estate investment trusts. The two asset classes give you a broader investment mix, as well as provide a large measure of protection against inflation.
Signing up for Wealthfront
Like other robo-advisors, Wealthfront starts by having you complete a questionnaire, the answers of which will provide the basis of your portfolio.
You need a minimum of $500 to begin, then Wealthfront fully manages your portfolio, including automatic dividend reinvesting, periodic portfolio rebalancing, and tax-loss harvesting.
Once again, the use of automated investing and index-based ETFs enables Wealthfront to provide professional portfolio management at a very low fee.
Learn more about Wealthfront: Read our full review or visit their site!
We thought it would be helpful to include a comparison of investment performance between the two robo-advisor giants. However, due to limited performance data provided by Betterment, the comparison is no better than approximate. Also, individual portfolios will vary in their asset allocations based on investment goals, time horizons, and investor risk tolerance.
In the absence of an exact side-by-side comparison of precisely matching portfolios, we’ve done some number crunching and come up with what we believe to be a reasonable approximation of the investment performance for both over the past few years.
Betterment provides a historical performance tool that offers somewhat limited investment return data. The screenshot below shows an interactive graph enabling you to calculate returns over various time frames, going all the way back to 2004 (which is a tad meaningless, given the platform was only launched in 2008).
We set the graph from October, 2011, because it lines up with Wealthfront’s data going back to its inception on October 14, 2011. However, the Betterment results only extend through July, 2018, while Wealthfront’s are continuous, allowing us to use results through February, 2019.
Betterment’s investment results from October, 2011, through July, 2018, show an 82.6% return, based on a portfolio with an 80% stock allocation.
But in doing our best to maintain a relative apples-to-apples comparison, we blended the performance of the 80% stock allocation with a 70% allocation, because that aligns more consistently with Wealthfront’s stock allocations. That produces a blended return of 77.8% over 82 months. That works out to an average annual return of just under 8.8%.
Wealthfront provides a regularly updated report on its historical returns. The screenshot below shows Wealthfront investment results through February 28, 2019, for both taxable portfolios and tax-advantaged portfolios (retirement accounts).
They’re displayed for one year, three years, five years, and since the inception of Wealthfront on October 14, 2011.
Now as is always the case with investment returns, these results require a significant amount of explanation. The investment return for each time frame is compared with a comparative benchmark. The benchmark includes the same asset allocations and ETFs used in the actual portfolios with the same risk scores.
However, the benchmark does not include advisory fees or trading costs due to bid/ask spreads. As a result, the Wealthfront investment results are consistently slightly below the corresponding comparative benchmark.
Both the taxable and nontaxable portfolios are weighted heavily in favor of US and international stocks. The taxable portfolio includes upwards of 80% in stocks, with the balance invested in fixed income, natural resources, and real estate. Nontaxable portfolios have a somewhat lower stock allocation, again with the balance invested in fixed income, natural resources, and real estate.
The above results are for a portfolio based on an investor with a risk score of 8.0. This is just one of 20 potential asset allocations, since the Wealthfront risk scores run in increments of .5, from .5 up to 10. The results will be different for each risk score level, which is part of what makes it difficult to make a direct comparison with Betterment or any other investment platform.
Betterment vs. Wealthfront Investment performance conclusion
Based on the numbers above, Betterment has an average annual investment return of just under 8.8%. Wealthfront is at 7.62% on its taxable portfolios, and 8.52% on its tax-advantaged portfolios.
While it may appear that Betterment has the better performance, be reminded that there are timing differences. Notably, the data on Betterment runs only through July, 2018.
Given that the fourth quarter of 2018 was unusually volatile, that can skew the performance data in favor of Betterment. As well, Wealthfront discloses that their performance numbers account for advisory fees and bid/ask spreads, while Betterment is silent on this issue.
So there you have it – it’s not quite an apples-to-apples comparison, but it’s as close as we can get based on the public data available.
- You can open an account with no money at all
- Human assisted investment advice
- Tax-loss harvesting on all taxable accounts
- Customer support includes live chat
- One low fee of 0.25% on all accounts up to $2 million
- Fee drops to 0.15% on accounts above $2 million
- Stock allocations include large- , medium- , and small-cap value stocks
- Smart Beta option
- Socially responsible investment option
- Personal financial advisor with an annual fee of 0.40% (minimum $100,000 balance)
- External account analysis, including 401(k) plans
- Low minimum initial investment, at $500
- Low annual advisory fee of 0.25% on all account balances
- Your portfolio includes natural resources stocks and real estate
- Financial planning tools
- Portfolio line of credit available on account balances over $100,000
- Cash account option
- Smart Beta option
- Socially responsible investment option
- 529 college savings accounts available
- Individual stocks used in larger portfolios
- No diversification into alternative investments, like real estate and natural resources
- Lower fees are offered, but not available to the typical investor ($2 million minimum)
- Provides analysis of external accounts, but does not consider them in asset allocations
- No reduction in fees for larger portfolios
- $500 required to open an account, though this is not a major obstacle
- Smart Beta option requires minimum investment of $500,000
Use of value stocks
Betterment’s asset allocation includes small-, medium-, and large-cap value stocks in each portfolio. This holds the potential to outperform the general stock market, as measured by the S&P 500.
Value stocks represent companies that are largely shunned by investors, but are fundamentally sound, and can produce above average gains over the long term.
Financial advisors available on portfolios over $100,000
Betterment’s Premium plan offers access to live financial advisors, and an annual advisory fee of just 0.40%. This is a fraction of the 1% to 2% fee charged by traditional human financial advisors.
Betterment also offers a series of financial advice packages, with fees ranging from $149 to $399. The packages address basic financial planning, such as preparing for college, marriage, and retirement.
Socially Responsible Investing (SRI)
Betterment replaces emerging market stocks and large-cap US stocks with three ETFs dedicated to socially responsible investing. Your entire portfolio won’t be fully SRI, but a large portion will be.
Managed by Goldman Sachs, this portfolio works to outperform the conventional market cap strategy. It involves an actively managed portfolio, offering potentially higher rewards with correspondingly higher risks. This portfolio requires a minimum investment of $100,000.
Betterment EverydayTM Cash Reserve
Betterment’s EverydayTM Cash Reserve offers a APY. You won’t need a minimum balance and you’ll pay no monthly fees. Plus, you’ll also be able to make an unlimited number of withdrawals (typically, you can only make six).
Betterment will also be offering an Everyday Checking account – you’ll need to put your name on the waitlist. It comes with no fees, no minimum balance, and reimbursed ATM fees.
This option allows you to adjust the individual asset class weights in your portfolio. It’s an option intended only for seasoned investors, providing some control over portfolio allocation, while still enjoying the benefits of automated investing.
Similar to Betterment, Wealthfront’s Smart Beta seeks to outperform the general market. It does this by deemphasizing market capitalization as a primary factor in portfolio construction. This leads to a more even distribution of stocks within the portfolio. It represents a form of active portfolio management, and is available for portfolios of $500,000 or more.
Stock-level tax-loss harvesting
This might be Wealthfront’s most interesting feature. They offer three different portfolios that enable you to diversify into individual stocks. For example, up to 500 stocks will be purchased out of the S&P 500 index. Depending on the account size, up to 1,000 stocks will be chosen from the S&P 1500 index. These portfolios allow for greater efficiency with tax-loss harvesting, since individual stocks offer more flexibility than entire ETFs. This category requires a portfolio between $100,000 and $500,000.
Wealthfront Risk Parity
This is a more complex investment strategy, but one that has shown higher long-term returns. It does this by allocating the portfolio in a way that equalizes the risk contributions of each asset class. Since the strategy uses leverage with certain positions in the portfolio it is higher risk. Participation does require a larger account balance.
Wealthfront Portfolio line of credit
This line is available for clients with accounts totaling $100,000 or more. It enables you to borrow up to 30% of your account value, and make repayments on your own schedule.
The line of credit is secured by your portfolio, which eliminates application or qualification based on credit or income. It’s not designed to be a margin loan, but it offers you total flexibility. Funds can be borrowed for any purpose, and since you’re borrowing from yourself, you can repay on your own terms.
This is something of a financial advisory, but it’s software-based. It provides financial planning tools to help you plan for retirement, home ownership, saving for the down payment on a house, and college funding for your children.
The app can be used to run “what if scenarios”, such as seeing the projections of increasing your savings or determining how much financial aid your child might be eligible for in college. You can even look for a house through the connection with Zillow.com.
Betterment and Wealthfront have become the largest independent robo-advisors because they’ve been in the forefront of the phenomenon that is automated investing. Both have a long line of satisfied investment clients, and each has continued to innovate from the basic robo-advisor model.
Which is the better of the two? There is no definitive answer to that question. It really depends on the various services and features each provides that will best fit your own personal needs.
For example, if you prefer diversification into alternative investments, like real estate and natural resources, Wealthfront will be your choice. But if you prefer investing in value stocks, Betterment will be the better option.
Otherwise, the two platforms are largely identical. Considering the direct competition between the two, that’s hardly surprising. Each charges a basic fee of 0.25% for the vast majority of investors. Each offers smart beta, socially responsible investing, various forms of financial advice, and the ability to open an account with little or no money.
In the final analysis, both Betterment and Wealthfront platforms. In fact, where each has distinguished itself from the many robo-advisor platforms now available is that they have trade-up options. As your portfolio grows, each offers the ability to take advantage of more sophisticated investment options. These are the kind of investment strategies more typically available with higher cost, traditional investment advisors.
In truth, you can’t go wrong with either of these platforms. Look carefully at the features that will work best for you, and make your choice accordingly.
- Betterment Review: The Way Investing Should Be
- Wealthfront Review: Automated Investing And Financial Planning That’s Free Up To $10,000